McCloud Judgment and Remedy FAQs - Public Service Pensions and Judicial Offices Act 2022

NICS Pension Schemes - McCloud Judgment Remedy FAQs

What about immediate detriment/rectification cases? Why can’t these be processed now the Bill has received Royal Assent?

It is accepted that affected members of the reformed pension schemes who have retired since 1 April 2015 or will retire before the remedy has been implemented, have an entitlement to be treated as a member of their legacy scheme for the remedy period if they wish.

However, giving effect to this entitlement before legislation is implemented creates complex issues, particularly where there are interactions with the tax system.

The PSPJOA 2022, together with changes being made through tax regulations using powers in the Finance Act will ensure a consistent approach and mitigate the risk of adverse tax impacts for members once they are commenced through scheme regulations.

These scheme regulations will be in place by October 2023 for all members and schemes may implement them earlier where it is possible to do so.

When will those who are suffering immediate detriment see their benefits amended?

Provisions for the deferred choice will be implemented by 1 October 2023 (or earlier where this is possible) for all active members who retire beyond this point. Schemes will also offer those who have already retired a choice of benefits for the remedy period as quickly as possible after scheme regulations are implemented.

Where cases may have been processed ahead of legislation they will need to be revisited.

If I retire before October 2023, what pension benefits will I receive?

Where members retire before the deferred choice is implemented in their pension scheme, they will initially receive benefits from their current scheme.

They will then be given a choice of benefits for the remedy period as quickly as possible after that and any increased entitlement will be backdated.

Does Royal Assent mean that all of the legislation to remedy McCloud is now in place?

No. There are still detailed changes that need to be made to scheme regulations. These will be made using the powers in the PSPJOA 2022 and need to be in force by 1 October 2023 at the latest.

There are also some situations where changes to pension rights due to the McCloud remedy produce disproportionate tax results that cannot be resolved through powers provided in the PSPJOA 2022.

Therefore, the Westminster Government will also be making changes to tax legislation to ensure that the remedy can be implemented smoothly. The intention is to finalise these regulations by Autumn 2022 with a public consultation planned in Summer 2022.

Does the PSPJOA remedy the discrimination identified by the Court of Appeal?

Together with changes being made through tax regulations using the powers in the Finance Act and scheme regulations made under the Act, the PSPJOA will provide a remedy for all those affected by the discrimination identified by the Court of Appeal.

This remedy will apply equally to claimants in the employment tribunal and non-claimants and there is no need to make a claim to the employment tribunal to benefit from the changes.


Return to FAQ Topics

Related articles

Back to top